Trust Your Signal9 min read

Why You Keep Choosing Men Who Can’t Stay

Why you can keep giving more to a man who will not choose you—and the old emotional charge that can make the pattern feel like love.

By Bernhard Thilo

You may keep finding men who cannot stay.

Maybe they are married. Maybe they are emotionally shut down. Maybe they give very little effort. Maybe they are technically with you, but they never really choose you. You are always waiting for the next sign that you matter. The next good day. The next message. The next time he is warm enough for you to believe that this could finally become real.

And then you give more.

More patience. More understanding. More of your time. More excuses for him. More of yourself.

You tell yourself that if you love him well enough, support him enough, wait long enough, do not ask for too much, or become easier to be with, he will finally see what you are worth.

But there is a sentence many women need to hear.

You cannot give so much of yourself that it makes another person choose you.

And if you are constantly trying to earn being chosen, then the first person disappearing from the relationship is usually you.

This does not mean every man who moves slowly is unavailable. It does not mean that a good relationship has to become serious overnight. Some people have history. Some have children. Some need time. A new relationship needs room to grow.

But there is a difference between giving something time and living in a permanent waiting room.

If you are always confused, always chasing, always explaining away what hurts you, always trying to become more lovable so that he will finally come toward you, then you need to stop looking only at him.

You need to ask what keeps bringing you back to the same kind of man.

The man is different. The feeling is not.

You may tell yourself that this time is different because the details are different.

The last man was married. This one is divorced. The last one was cold. This one is sweet when he wants something. The last one disappeared. This one comes back after a few days and acts as if nothing happened.

Different costume. Same feeling.

You are waiting to be chosen. You are trying to prove that you are enough. You are giving more when the other person gives less.

And somewhere inside, you may already know the ending before it happens. You are afraid he will not stay. That is why every small sign of warmth becomes so important. You need it to mean that all the waiting, giving, hoping, and hurting will finally be worth it.

That is not a good place to build love from.

This is what Orlando calls an emotional treibmine: an old charge that has been floating around inside you for years. Somebody touches it, and suddenly you are not only dealing with the man in front of you. You are dealing with every time you felt unseen, not chosen, replaceable, or somehow not enough.

The present man becomes the latest person who might finally give you a different ending.

And that is a heavy job to give a man.

Sometimes the relationship is painful most of the time. Then he gives you one beautiful day.

He is attentive. He is warm. He tells you something that sounds like love. He touches you in the way you have been missing. For a moment, everything feels right again.

Then it disappears.

And instead of seeing the whole pattern, your mind holds on to that one good day. See? He can be wonderful. See? There is something here. See? If I just do this right, maybe we can get back to that.

That is how you can end up gambling with your own heart.

You are not staying because the relationship is consistently good. You are staying for the next moment of relief. The next sign that you matter. The next little proof that the story might turn out differently.

But rare warmth is not the same thing as a real relationship.

A man who genuinely wants to build something with you does not have to be perfect. He may have problems. He may make mistakes. He may need time.

But over time, he makes you more clear, not more confused. More solid, not smaller. More able to be yourself, not more desperate to earn your place.

This part is difficult.

You may say that you want a man who is available, clear, loving, and ready to build a real relationship. And you may mean it.

But another part of you may be drawn to the man who cannot fully choose you because the whole relationship stays unfinished.

As long as he does not truly come close, he never gets the full chance to see you and reject you.

As long as you are still trying to win him, you can tell yourself that the final verdict has not happened yet. You can keep working. You can keep hoping. You can keep giving.

It hurts. But it can also feel familiar.

A good man can be frightening in a different way. He may actually be present. He may actually want to know you. He may actually give you something real to receive.

Then you cannot hide behind the chase anymore. You have to let yourself be seen.

That is why a woman can sometimes say she wants love while repeatedly choosing situations where love never has to become fully real.

This is not a moral failure. It is not a reason to attack yourself. It is something to see.

Because what you do not see keeps choosing for you.

When you are inside this pattern, all of your attention goes to him. Does he care? Is he talking to someone else? Why did he say that? Why did he not answer? What can I do so that he finally chooses me?

But there is another question.

Why are you giving all of yourself to a man who is not giving you a place to stand?

Do not use that question to shame yourself. Use it to come back to yourself.

The first relationship that needs your attention is the one with you.

You are allowed to want a man who chooses you. You are allowed to want commitment, honesty, warmth, sex, consistency, and a relationship that makes your life bigger.

You do not have to become cold to protect yourself.

But you do have to stop calling self-abandonment love.

Giving all of yourself to somebody who will not meet you there is not proof that you love deeply. It may be proof that an old wound has made you believe you have to bleed in order to be loved.

Do not decide your whole future in the middle of a panic.

First, name three things. What actually happened? Not the whole story. Did he cancel? Did he not answer? Did he say that he does not want a relationship? Did he break an agreement?

Then name what your mind is telling you. Write the ugly version. Nobody stays. I am not enough. If I stop giving, he will leave. I have to make him choose me.

Then name what you are feeling in your body. Is it the hollow feeling? The panic? The fear of being replaced? The old pain of not being chosen?

Now you have something real to work with.

Not him. Not every man you have ever known. Not your entire childhood. Not the entire future of love.

The one live charge that has you right now.

This is where The Kugel has a job.

Use it for the part of you that is desperate to make him choose you. Use it for the feeling that says you are nothing without his answer. Use it for the fear that if you stop giving, nobody will stay.

The Kugel is not there to make an unavailable man available. It is not there to make you accept bad treatment. It is not there to tell you whether to stay or leave.

It is there to get you out of the emotional prison long enough to see what is really happening and decide what you will participate in.

When the charge is not writing your next message, you may still choose to have a conversation. You may still decide that this man cannot give you what you need. You may still have to grieve.

But you will be doing it from a place that has more of you in it.

And that is where the pattern starts to break.

If you are currently unsafe, being threatened, coerced, abused, or feel at risk of harming yourself, seek immediate local emergency help, a qualified mental-health professional, or a trusted person who can be with you. This article and The Kugel are relationship education, not emergency or clinical care.

Continue with OPEN

The article names the pattern. The book gives you the fuller way through it.

Visit the OPEN companion page for a quieter, more personal place to begin applying the ideas you have just read.

Continue reading